At the end of July, a further version of the draft amendment to the DRS legislation also addressed tax issues. Although it takes into account a significant part of the postulates made by future participants of the system, the solutions proposed in it as to the settlement of VAT in the bail system opens new…
Another German VAT group question The CJEU judgment of 11.7.2024 in case C-184/23 is another judgment on VAT groups. The preliminary question in this case was (again) initiated by the German Federal Fiscal Court, which has recently been ‘actively’ asking the Court about the nature of VAT groups. This is interesting as VAT groups in…
8% or 5% VAT rate in catering? On Monday 24 June this year the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) passed an important resolution (ref. I FPS 1/24) related to the application of VAT rates in the catering industry. Although the resolution relates to the legal situation prior to 2020, i.e. prior to the so-called VAT matrix,…
On 24 June 2024, the Supreme Administrative Court (hereinafter: NSA), in a judgment by seven judges [1], decided that the assignment of rights from a developer agreement constitutes a service subject to 23% VAT and, therefore, the reduced 8% VAT rate applicable to the supply of a residential unit does not apply. In its ruling,…
Although it has been the accepted position in Poland for many years that illegal consumption of energy or heat is not a VAT-taxable activity because the charges levied on illegal consumers is of a compensatory nature, this position was recently overturned by the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) in its judgment of 24 May 202 4,…
In a judgment of 17 May 2024 (ref. I FSK 1240/20), the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) ruled that fees charged in the event of termination of a contract due to the client’s fault perform a compensation function and are not subject to VAT. The NSA justified the above position with the lack of identifiability of…
ViDA – status of the project The negotiations on the EU package referred to as ViDA (VAT in the Digital Age) are entering a decisive phase. If it were not for Estonia’s opposition, the project would have been agreed even in May. It is worth pointing out that the disagreement concerned only certain elements of…
On 19 May 2024, Directive 2024/1226 entered into force, which introduces significant changes to the application and enforcement of EU sanctions imposed in connection with Russia’s aggression against Ukraine. Until now, EU Member States had full discretion in determining penalties for violations of existing sanctions. The differences resulting from the different legislation of EU countries…
Ministry of Finance general ruling: RES projects and asbestos removal in local government units outside VAT, but also without retroactive adjustment of settlements Following the judgments of the Court of Justice of the EU last year concerning municipal projects involving the installation of a RES system and the removal of asbestos from real estate (judgments…
Charging an electric vehicle at a network of charging points to which the user has access on the basis of a subscription contracted with a company other than the operator of the charging point means that the electricity consumed is supplied to users by that operator and the company offering access to those charging points…